The Echo of the Past: Understanding and Resolving Enactments

Each of us carries echoes of past relationships into the present, often unconsciously replaying old dynamics. This phenomenon, known as enactment, shapes our interactions in ways we may not fully understand. Recognising and addressing these patterns is essential for anyone seeking a conscious, emotionally responsible life, free from projections of unresolved pain.

 

The Persistent Echo of the Past

Enactments involve the unconscious repetition of unhealed relational patterns, rooted in attachment wounds and traumatic experiences. These patterns often go unrecognised, replaying in relationships until we acknowledge them and feel the depth of associated emotions that have previously been avoided. Only then can we move forward, no longer casting shadows on future interactions that might inadvertently hurt others and ourselves.

 

For example, imagine someone who experienced emotional unavailability from a caregiver during their formative years. In adulthood, this unresolved pattern might unconsciously drive them to seek out partners who are similarly distant or inconsistent. At first, they might be drawn to the excitement of an elusive partner, mistaking this feeling for genuine attraction. But over time, the familiar ache of unreciprocated attention resurfaces, replicating the original wound. This enactment, often driven by an unconscious hope that this time things will end differently, can trap both partners in a cycle of pursuing and withdrawing—a dynamic that inevitably stirs up unresolved pain unless consciously addressed.

 

In another instance, someone who grew up in a controlling environment where their autonomy was stifled might, as an adult, unconsciously perceive others’ harmless suggestions or mild feedback as attempts to control them, even when the intention is supportive. This could lead to defensiveness or even hostility in situations where no actual threat exists, replaying a battle against perceived control. Without realising it, they cast their partner or friend in the role of an “oppressor,” recreating dynamics from the past that lead to conflict or tension. The enactment here lies in projecting their unhealed experience onto others, treating them as stand-ins for the original figures of their unresolved pain, which ultimately strains relationships and prevents genuine connection.

 

The Drive for Resolution

Sigmund Freud’s concept of repetition compulsion has evolved in contemporary psychotherapy, where it’s understood that our psyche seeks to recreate past situations to gain mastery over unresolved conflicts. This drive is not about merely repeating the past but seeking a different outcome. Therapy becomes a safe space where these patterns are illuminated, origins understood, and new pathways forged for healthier relationships.

 

Understanding Psychological Defence Mechanisms

Psychological defences like repression, denial, and projection protect our inner world but can also perpetuate harmful patterns if left unchecked. For example, repression pushes painful memories out of conscious reach, while denial shields us by refusing to accept reality. Projection involves attributing unacceptable thoughts and feelings to others. These defences protect us from distress but can trap us in harmful patterns that might cause pain - or even abuse - to those unknowingly enlisted in these dramas.

 

Absorbing the Abuser’s Thoughts and Feelings

Consider how someone who, over time, has absorbed negative messages about their self-worth might carry these messages forward, treating themselves or others with disdain. These internalised patterns can distort one’s relationships and sense of self. Sometimes, individuals may adopt behaviours they once experienced, projecting similar attitudes onto others and perpetuating cycles of pain.

 

The Impact of Unaddressed Enactments

Enactments can be complex and, if left unexamined, may create toxic patterns that affect not only ourselves but also those closest to us. Without taking responsibility for understanding and healing these unconscious dynamics, we risk unintentionally enlisting others into harmful roles that repeat unresolved pain. This process can be damaging, even dangerous, for relationships and family systems.

 

Therapy plays a critical role here. It offers a structured and safe environment to uncover and heal these complex histories, guiding us toward self-awareness and healthier ways of relating. By taking responsibility for our own healing, we prevent past wounds from casting shadows on our lives and those around us, fostering relationships rooted in respect, compassion, and genuine connection.

 

Enactments Beyond Relationships

Enactments extend beyond personal relationships, influencing professional and social interactions. These patterns adapt to any context echoing original pain, replaying old dynamics until understood. Therapy uses these enactments as opportunities for self-understanding and change, fostering vulnerability and empathy to break free from such patterns.

​

Breaking Through Defences

Well-established defences often require life crises or hitting rock bottom for breakthrough, creating opportunities for profound therapeutic work. These moments, historically called “breakdowns,” are now recognised as critical junctures where old defences no longer suffice, allowing space for growth and healing.

 

Achieving Genuine Resolution

True resolution goes beyond merely repeating the past; it involves processing and integrating these experiences to reduce their emotional charge. Techniques like psychodynamic and humanistic therapies allow clients to gently explore and integrate these painful experiences, gradually reducing symptoms like flashbacks and nightmares.

 

Integrating Indigenous and Transpersonal Perspectives

Indigenous perspectives view trauma as a collective and intergenerational experience affecting entire communities. This view resonates with the concept of a “curse” that lingers across generations. Transpersonal therapy, which I often incorporate, brings further insights. It values the unconscious’s capacity to reveal itself through symbols and creativity, allowing clients to express and process trauma non-verbally, facilitating profound healing.

 

The Importance of a Strong Therapeutic Alliance

Working with deep, painful enactments requires a strong therapeutic alliance. Trust, empathy, and respect between therapist and client create a safe space for exploring these wounds. This alliance is the foundation for long-term therapeutic work, allowing clients to access and heal parts of themselves that often remain hidden.

 

The Role of Boundaries in Therapy and Life

Boundaries are crucial in therapy and life, as they foster trust, respect, and mutual understanding. A strong sense of self and healthy boundaries protect individuals from being drawn into another’s unconscious enactment—a process known as scapegoating. In therapy, boundaries ensure a professional focus on the client’s well-being, while in life, they protect individuals from manipulation and unhealthy dynamics.

 

The Risks of Rigid Defence Mechanisms

While defence mechanisms like repression or denial can temporarily shield us from painful emotions, rigid defences often prevent growth and damage relationships. When these defences become inflexible, they trap us in cycles of unconscious repetition, blocking our ability to engage openly with ourselves and others. This rigidity often signals the presence of deeper, unexamined material hidden in the unconscious, much like a “drawbridge” dropped to protect what lies beneath.

 

Psychoanalytic theory, as posited by Freud and later expanded by Melanie Klein, suggests that rigid defences serve as barriers against intense feelings of vulnerability, guilt, or unresolved conflict. For example, someone who has experienced abandonment may rigidly deny their dependency needs, adopting an overly independent stance to shield themselves from past hurt. While this defence can offer temporary relief, it often prevents the individual from forming genuine connections, as their need for self-protection overrides their ability to be vulnerable.

 

Example: The “Drawbridge” Defence

Imagine a partner who insists on always being “right” in conflicts, unable to consider alternative viewpoints. This stance could signal a “drawbridge” defence—an unconscious barrier protecting feelings of insecurity or unworthiness. According to attachment theory, as researched by John Bowlby, these rigid stances can stem from early relational experiences that shaped one’s sense of safety and worthiness. When threatened, this individual’s defence mechanism closes off dialogue, preventing any introspection that could reveal the vulnerability they are defending against.

 

Such rigid defences not only block authentic intimacy but also perpetuate relational pain, as partners may feel unheard, unvalued, or even scapegoated. Therapy becomes a valuable space for safely exploring these entrenched patterns, offering the individual an opportunity to gradually dismantle their “drawbridge” and allow a more open, adaptive approach to relationships. Through this process, they can achieve greater self-awareness, deepen their emotional capacity, and engage more flexibly, paving the way for mutual understanding and healing.

 

The Gift of Awareness

Recognising and transforming deep-seated patterns is a profound act of psychological, emotional, and spiritual responsibility. It allows us to stop using others as stand-ins for past relationships, to treat ourselves and others with respect and compassion. This awareness is a gift to humanity and those we love, but most importantly, it is a gift to ourselves, enabling us to experience life without the weight of unhealed shadows.

 

Conclusion

Enactments reveal the unconscious forces shaping our lives. Through therapy, we illuminate these patterns, offering insights into our relational dynamics and paving the way for emotional liberation. Together, we will explore these dynamics with curiosity and compassion, transforming them into opportunities for healing and growth.

For more information or to schedule a session, please email sarah@hampshirecounselling.com
 

Recommended Books on Trauma and Psychological Reenactment

       1.      “The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma” by Bessel van der Kolk
A seminal work that explores how trauma affects the body and mind, offering comprehensive insights into therapeutic techniques for healing.
       2.      “It Didn’t Start with You: How Inherited Family Trauma Shapes Who We Are and How to End the Cycle” by Mark Wolynn
This book delves into the science of epigenetics and provides practical strategies for breaking the cycle of inherited trauma.
       3.      “What Happened to You?: Conversations on Trauma, Resilience, and Healing” by Oprah Winfrey and Bruce D. Perry
A series of conversations that blend scientific insights with personal stories, exploring the effects of trauma and pathways to resilience.
       4.      “The Complex PTSD Workbook: A Mind-Body Approach to Regaining Emotional Control and Becoming Whole” by Arielle Schwartz
A practical workbook with exercises and strategies for managing and healing from complex PTSD.
       5.      “The Choice: Embrace the Possible” by Dr. Edith Eva Eger
A moving memoir that offers profound insights into overcoming trauma and finding freedom from past wounds.
       6.      “Traumatized: Identify, Understand, and Cope with PTSD and Emotional Stress” by Kati Morton
Addresses various sources of trauma and provides clear, practical advice on recognising and coping with PTSD and emotional stress.
       7.      “Struggle Well: Thriving in the Aftermath of Trauma” by Ken Falke and Josh Goldberg
Emphasises the potential for growth after trauma, offering stories and strategies to help readers turn pain into strength and peace.

Contemporary Films Dealing with Trauma and Reenactment

       1.      “Manchester By the Sea” (2017): Directed by Kenneth Lonergan and starring Casey Affleck and Michelle Williams, this film explores the trauma experienced by a man after a personal tragedy. The story delves into the deep emotional scars and the process of attempting to rebuild one’s life amidst overwhelming grief. 

       2.      “The Perks of Being a Wallflower” (2012): Starring Logan Lerman, Emma Watson, and Ezra Miller, this film portrays a young boy’s struggle with PTSD following the loss of his aunt. The narrative focuses on his high school experiences and the supportive friendships that help him confront and heal from his trauma. 

       3.      “A Beautiful Mind” (2001): Starring Russell Crowe, this biographical film about John Nash, a Nobel Laureate in Economics, deals with his battle with schizophrenia. The movie highlights his struggles with his mental health condition and the impact on his personal and professional life.